Favourite Guidebook?

I have a slightly ambivalent relationship with guidebooks. After all, any walker worth their salt should surely be able to devise perfectly acceptable walks from an OS map – all the information you need is there. Indeed, by choosing a route off the shelf, it could be argued that you’re missing part of the pleasure of planning a walk. But, despite my slightly begrudging feeling towards them, my collection of walking guidebooks continues to inexorably grow.

So, I was wondering – do you have a favourite guidebook?

I suppose that lots of fell-walkers would plump for Wainwright. Or maybe one of the guides to the Munros – perhaps Irvine Butterfield’s book? Or the SMC guides? I suppose which is your favourite might, in part at least, be not just a function of your location but also of your age, after all these are all quite old books, and whilst the hills maybe haven’t changed much, new guidebooks seem to appear all the time.

When I started to think about this question, I didn’t have to consider for too long before I knew what would be my clear choice. I’m very fond of the books of Aileen and R. Brian Evans, the scramble guides…


..and the ‘Short Walks in Lakeland’ series, but ultimately I would have to choose ‘High Peak Walks’ by my namesake Mark Richards…


…and not only because I used to try to impress people by letting them think that I had written it myself. (It didn’t work for long: there’s a photo of the actual author on the front endpiece.)

The first guidebook I bought, it is handwritten with hand-drawn maps and heavily illustrated with hatched line drawings. In other words, it’s very much in the style of Wainwright’s guides, although I’m not sure that I realised that when I bought it. My copy has slightly wavy pages having been dampened a few times when carried in a rucksack on the hill.  Unlike any other guidebook I’ve bought since, with the notable exception, for obvious reasons, of the Evans’ guide to the Arnside and SIlverdale area , I think that I’ve done just about every walk in it. And Walk 6 – ‘Bleaklow Head and Higher Shelf Stones from Old Glossop’, I walked again and again, in the days when a number 53 bus from Manchester was my favoured transport to the hills. Usually, we took the alternative route across Shelf Benches and into Dowstone Clough, where I don’t remember ever meeting any other walkers. Peering into the book again now, I see that the section of path between Shelf Stones and Bleaklow Head is labelled ‘unremitting hell!’.

In fact, flicking through the book, and finding another favourite walk – a short route exploring Near, Far and Middle Black Cloughs near Woodhead, I realise that it was in following pathless routes like these, up Dowstone Clough, or Far Black Clough, that I gained the confidence to ask: why not follow Wildboar Clough instead ? or Shining Clough? And then began to branch out onto routes not covered in the guidebook.

Anyway, what prompted these musings when I already have several recent, and not so recent, walks to write up? Well – another question: when Grace Jones assaulted Russell Harty mid-chatshow, who was the other guest?


A clue:


Walter Poucher!

I heard a radio programme about him, and thought that maybe readers of this blog, or the older, hill-walking readers at least, might be interested. Turns out that he was quite an odd ball. As well as being the preeminent mountain photographer of his day, he was also a parfumier for Yardley’s, and would often take to the hills heavily made-up. The Radio 4 programme about him, ‘The Perfumed Mountaineer’ is here.

So – favourite guide books anyone?

Favourite Guidebook?

11 thoughts on “Favourite Guidebook?

  1. qdant says:

    Hi Mark, mines in my profile :-
    Harry Speight – Craven & the North West Yorkshire Highlands (1892)
    other wise it’s Memorymap’s OS 25:1 with the field walls, once they stoped showing them, was a sad day in my opinion – cheers Danny

    1. beatingthebounds says:

      Thanks Danny – I don’t know that one, I shall be on the look out now though.
      Did the OS stop showing field boundaries on 1:25,000’s. Why? That’s their main advantage over the Landranger maps. That’s a ridiculous thing to do. Who do I write to?

    1. beatingthebounds says:

      The OS 1:50000 don’t have walls, which is usually Ok in the Scottish highlands, but is a bit useless elsewhere.
      Thanks for that link, isn’t the internet wonderful (some times at least). I shall enjoy perusing this.

  2. I used to have a Poucher book of the Lake District, but I think it must have been recycled as I can’t find it.
    Anyway, my favourite guide book is not really a ‘proper’ guide book, but a ‘kind of’ guide book – ‘Walking the Peak and Pennines’ by Mike Harding. It’s a coffee table kind of book, with great narrative and photos, and my step-daughter bought it for me for Christmas in 1996.

    1. beatingthebounds says:

      My Dad has a companion volume which covers the Yorkshire Dales. I think I bought it for him. Saw Mike Harding live once at the Theatre in the Forest in Grizedale. I’d heard some of the stories before (my Dad has several records of Mike live), but even so, I laughed so much I cried. Does he do comedy these days, or just his Radio 2 folk programme?

      1. I think he may just be doing his folk programme nowadays. I saw him live once at Halifax back in the 1980s, and a few years ago, he was sat behind us at a Nancy Griffith concert at The Lowry theatre – I was too shy to ask for his autograph though!

  3. We bought only a handful of guidebooks over the years, the major ones being the 2-volume set of the Nuttalls’ ‘Mountains of England and Wales’ and the 2-volume set of Peter Hermon’s ‘Hillwalking in Wales’, both excellent.
    Years ago we also had Mark Richards’ ‘Dark Peak’ and ‘White Peak’ walks, and more recently Paddy Dillon’s Galloway and North Pennines books.
    Buying a book is very rare nowadays, I use a combination of poring over extensive digital mapping with Memory-map and articles / trip reports from websites and blogs.

    1. beatingthebounds says:

      I have the Nuttalls’ two volume guide to the Tarns of Lakeland and very good it is too. I picked up the English part of the Mountains guide second-hand last week. It’s a compunction – I don’t need guidebooks but…..
      Since Chrissie and Danny seem to have extended the remit somewhat, I’d have to put in a vote for A. Harry Griffin’s books about the Lakes. I’m rationing his Guardian diaries book at the moment, trying to make it last.

  4. Have to agree that the Mark Richards guides to the Peak are superb, great line drawings and interesting descriptions as well as really well thought out routes. Your best work to date 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s